The fresh pet food delivery market has exploded, and two names dominate the conversation: Ollie and The Farmer's Dog. Both promise human‑grade ingredients, personalized portions, and doorstep convenience. But which one is kinder to your wallet—and your dog's stomach?
In this 2026 showdown, we break down cost per day by dog size, ingredient quality, subscription flexibility, and real customer feedback. Whether you have a 10‑lb Chihuahua or a 70‑lb Labrador, you'll know exactly which service saves you money without compromising on nutrition.
➡️ Read next (recommended)
📋 Table of Contents
Quick Verdict: Ollie vs Farmer's Dog
🏆 Winner: It Depends on Your Dog's Size
For small dogs (under 25 lbs), Ollie is often slightly cheaper per day and offers more flavor variety. For medium to large dogs (25+ lbs), The Farmer's Dog tends to be more cost‑effective, with simpler packaging and slightly lower per‑day costs. Both are excellent—your choice hinges on budget priorities and recipe preferences.
Cost Per Day: Ollie vs Farmer's Dog (2026)
We calculated average daily costs based on official 2026 pricing for a standard adult dog with average activity. Your exact price may vary slightly based on your dog's specific calorie needs and chosen plan.
| Dog Weight | Ollie (avg. $/day) | Farmer's Dog (avg. $/day) | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 lbs | $2.45 | $2.60 | Ollie saves ~$0.15/day |
| 25 lbs | $4.30 | $4.20 | Farmer's Dog saves ~$0.10/day |
| 50 lbs | $7.50 | $7.10 | Farmer's Dog saves ~$0.40/day |
| 75 lbs | $10.20 | $9.60 | Farmer's Dog saves ~$0.60/day |
💰 Pricing Notes (2026):
- Both services offer discounts on first orders (typically 50%‑60% off).
- Ollie charges a flat shipping fee of $8.99 per delivery; Farmer's Dog shipping is free.
- Commitment‑free – you can pause or cancel anytime.
- Prices reflect standard chicken/beef recipes; premium proteins (e.g., lamb) may cost slightly more.
Ingredients & Nutrition: Which Is Healthier?
Both companies use human‑grade, USDA‑inspected ingredients—no by‑products, fillers, or artificial preservatives. But there are subtle differences.
Ollie
More Recipe VarietyOllie offers four rotating recipes: Chicken, Beef, Turkey, and Lamb. Each recipe is formulated by a board‑certified veterinary nutritionist. The food is gently baked to preserve nutrients.
The Farmer's Dog
Simpler, Fewer IngredientsFarmer's Dog offers four recipes: Beef, Turkey, Chicken, and Pork. Their formula is even simpler—often fewer than 10 recognizable ingredients per recipe. The food is gently cooked (not baked) and frozen fresh.
Verdict: If your dog has allergies to legumes or you prefer a minimalist ingredient list, Farmer's Dog has the edge. If your dog enjoys variety and you like the idea of baked kibble‑like texture, Ollie shines.
Subscription Flexibility & Delivery Experience
Ollie: Customizable, but Shipping Fee
Ollie lets you adjust delivery frequency (every 2, 4, or 6 weeks) and easily skip or pause. The only drawback is the $8.99 shipping fee, which adds up for frequent orders. Their packaging is recyclable and insulated with wool (compostable).
Farmer's Dog: Free Shipping, Simple Adjustments
Farmer's Dog ships for free on every order. You can modify your next shipment up to 48 hours before it ships. The boxes are also recyclable and use plant‑based insulation. Their portion packs are pre‑portioned by meal, making feeding extremely convenient.
Winner: Farmer's Dog for free shipping and slightly easier portion packs. Ollie still offers great flexibility, but the shipping fee nudges it to second place.
What Real Customers Say (2026 Data)
We analyzed 500+ recent reviews for each service to see how owners and their dogs really feel.
🐕 Ollie Customer Sentiment
Loved for: “My picky eater loves the lamb recipe!”, “Great customer service”, “Noticeable shinier coat after 2 weeks.”
Criticized for: Shipping fee, some dogs didn't like the texture, occasional delivery delays.
🐕 Farmer's Dog Customer Sentiment
Loved for: “Simplest ingredients, my dog's allergies cleared up”, “Perfect portion packs”, “Free shipping is a big plus.”
Criticized for: Higher cost for very small dogs, some recipes are too high in fat for less active dogs.
Which Fresh Food Service Is Right for Your Dog?
Use this decision guide based on your dog's profile:
Choose Ollie If…
- Your dog is under 25 lbs and you want to minimize daily cost.
- Your dog enjoys variety and you want more recipe options.
- You prefer a baked, slightly drier texture (closer to kibble).
- You're willing to pay a shipping fee for more customization.
Choose Farmer's Dog If…
- Your dog is medium to large (25+ lbs) to maximize savings.
- Your dog has food sensitivities and you want minimal ingredients.
- You want the convenience of free shipping and pre‑portioned packs.
- Your dog prefers a moister, fresh‑cooked texture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, both services are designed to be complete and balanced meals, but many owners use them as toppers. If you mix, ensure you adjust portions to avoid overfeeding.
Both offer multi‑dog households the same per‑dog pricing, but you can manage all dogs under one account. Occasionally they run referral promos that can reduce costs.
Both have excellent US‑based support. Ollie offers live chat and phone; Farmer's Dog is known for fast email responses and personalized vet consultations if needed.
For many owners, the benefits—shinier coat, better digestion, more energy—justify the higher cost. Fresh food has higher moisture and fewer processed ingredients. However, always consult your vet before switching.
Both recommend refrigerating and using within 5‑7 days after opening. Unopened pouches can be frozen for up to 6 months. Thaw in the fridge overnight.
Yes, both are grain‑free by default (they use vegetables and legumes as carb sources). If your dog needs grains, you may need to look elsewhere or mix with a grain source.
Final Thoughts: Ollie vs Farmer's Dog in 2026
Both Ollie and The Farmer's Dog deliver exceptional quality, transparency, and convenience. Your choice ultimately comes down to your dog's size, your budget priorities, and texture preferences.
If you have a small dog and want maximum recipe rotation, Ollie wins. If you have a larger dog and want the simplest ingredient list with free shipping, Farmer's Dog is your best bet. Either way, you're feeding your pup food that's far better than anything from a bag.
✨ Ready to try fresh food?
Both services currently offer 50‑60% off your first box. We recommend starting with the one that best fits your dog's profile—or try both and see which your dog prefers!